Gold Ribbon Banner
Sunday, May 26, 2019

Trust the locals to give the awesomely scary seas at the eastern end of the Pentland Firth the innocent sounding name ‘The Merry Men of Mey’, the sea state caused by wind and tide in opposition as the vast surging volume of water falls over submerged obstructions and drives around skerries and headlands.
These seas were surely the direct cause of the loss of the cement carrier Cemfjord 1,850,’84 and her complement of eight at the turn of the New Year in January 2015.

It has taken the Marine Accident Investigation Board (MAIB) nearly 15 months, but they have come up with a thorough and profoundly important report (reports are here), forensic in its analysis while giving a clear picture of the nature of the pressures on the experienced, hard working, and, yes, courageous skipper for whom they seem to have a great deal of respect. So the direct cause is almost certainly known, but it is the indirect causes which put her in jeopardy. Why was she where she was and in her condition? The report is very clear that this ship and others like her under such operating regimes and commercial pressures can be calamities waiting to happen.

The report should be a wake-up call (as if another one was needed) to protect and safeguard those like this skipper and crew, obliged to deliver their cargoes in the shortest time, and therefore lowest cost, by driving their ships hard in fair weather and foul. Just how foul that weather can be in waters like the Pentland Firth are clearly described. The report also indicates how such skippers and crews can be working their hearts out for invisible investment companies and distant managers who do not use their best endeavours to ensure the ships and their complements are as safe as they can be, and legally indeed should be.

Meanwhile, some flag states (often ‘flags of convenience’) protect themselves by passing paper surveys, reports and ‘exemptions’ around on vessels regarding safety matters that anyone in the shipping business could admit were little more than fiction. Under the Cyprus Register’s regime Cemfjord had been inspected by the same surveyor twice a year for the previous seven years, during which time he had carried out seven full inspections and seven documentary verification inspections with no deficiencies ever having been noted”. Port State Control (PSC) inspectors had found several deficiencies and imposed detentions in that time. The report adds “Given the extent of defi ciencies identified by PSC inspectors during the same period, it is not credible for the non-exclusive surveyor to have found no shortcomings during his visits to Cemfjord. In the 13 months prior to her sinking, Cemfjord spent 54% of that time with noted shortcomings in safety related equipment; 40% relating to lifeboats and rafts. This was only possible because the Cyprus flag state, at the request of the managers, repeatedly sent out letters permitting temporary exemptions from the SOLAS regulations.

However, that the ship should not have been where she was at that time is unarguable.

Admiralty Sailing Directions give clear warnings. “Tidal streams are highly signifi cant to navigating in or through Pentland Firth and need to be considered at all times. They encounter a number of obstructions, which give rise to eddies and races, which, in several areas of the Firth, can be very strong and extremely violent. Tidal streams run with great strength, rates up to 16 kn have been reported… Masters should therefore ensure that a close watch is kept at all times on the course and speed of their vessels, which need… “sufficient power to overcome the strengths of the tidal streams. Low powered vessels, small vessels, and vessels under sail, whatever the weather, should avoid at all costs being drawn into any race which is at strength, in particular taking care to avoid Merry Men of Mey during the W-going stream….there is a heavy breaking sea, which can be dangerous to small coasters.”

She was sailing in a westerly gale gusting Force 10, precisely in the tidal conditions she should have avoided.

But look at the pressure on the captain and crew. She was late having had problems loading which had two effects. It almost certainly meant the cargo had not settled properly and therefore would be prone to shifting, and crucially it meant the crew were tired. She was heading into a Force 8-10 and the two unrested watch keeping officers, Captain and mate, fatigued and under time pressure, were heading into waters of great danger. The wise decision in these circumstances might have been to go south-about. Rordal (Aalborg) to Runcorn being 981nm via the Pentland Firth, by the English Channel, 1,187nm. That would mean more delay and cost to the company. That wasn’t this captain’s style. Anyway, recently a sister vessel Cemisle with a new captain had done just that and earned the query from the managers as to why he had chosen that route.

Maybe Cemfjord’s Captain in his fatigue and under great commercial pressures had miscalculated his timing into the Firth and underestimated the conditions there, but inexorably he would soon be in a position where he was unable to avoid the greatest danger. He had recently escaped a cargo shifting incident in the same waters in less serious conditions and he would know how vulnerable his ‘unsettled’ cargo would be to a change of course toward safety. And the ship’s best speed was a little more than 9 knots and in such currents, at times she would have no steering control and at best would go backwards.

More on this and other news in Sea Breezes Magazine - June 2016 Issue
Click here to subscribe

Subscribe Graphic

Latest Issue - Look Inside!

Island Princess

Most Popular

  • Port of London Trade at 10-Year High +

  • Ruminations on Rum +

  • Northlink Celebrates Apprentices +

  • Special Place for Tanker in Port History +

  • US Navy Seeks Faster Ship Delivery +

  • 1
  • 2

Latest Products

Maritime Log

  • South Atlantic Repair Yard Plans +

    BBDC Ship Repair Yard What will be the largest purpose-built shiprepair yard in the South Atlantic Basin is being developed in the state of Read More
  • Move to Enlarge River Terminal +

    Grimsby River Terminal Associated British Ports (ABP) plans to expand its Grimsby River Terminal to enable it to handle the world’s largest car Read More
  • At the Helm of the RNLI +

    Mark Dowie A new Chief Executive has been appointed by the Royal National Lifeboat Institution to succeed Paul Boissier, who has held Read More
  • Keeping the Tyne Clean +

    Clearwater Each year, the Clean Tyne project removes around 400 tonnes of debris from the River Tyne between Blaydon and the Read More
  • First Part of Huge Port Investment Completed +

    Sheerness Port The 20-year Master Plan for boosting trade through the Kent port of Sheerness has reached a significant milestone with the Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

North America

  • Houston Ship Canal Closed After Major Fire +

    Houston Fire The Houston Ship Canal reopened to daylight traffic after being closed for nearly a week due to a serious fire Read More
  • Back Home After Eventful Antarctic Season +

    Polar Star The US Coast Guard icebreaker Polar Star arrived back at her homeport of Seattle, Washington on Mar 11 after an Read More
  • Four More Giant Cranes Arrive from China +

    Zhen Hua 31 Four new Super-Post-Panamax container cranes arrived at Tacoma, Washington, from China in early March, just over a year after the Read More
  • Two Hurt as Lifeboat Falls Overboard +

    USCG Reliance Two crew members of the tanker Chemtrans Nova, 73,870dwt, had to be flown ashore for treatment after the lifeboat they Read More
  • Cutters Seize $466mn of Drugs on Patrols +

    USCG Forward At Port Everglades, Florida, on Feb 5, some 34,780lbs of cocaine with a street value of $466mn was unloaded from Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3


  • Three Main Courses Being Plotted for MOL +

    MOL Triumph The major Japanese shipping line Mitsui OSK Lines (MOL) has unveiled a number of new objectives aimed at improving its Read More
  • Cargo Ships for Bass Strait Service +

    Tasmanian Achiever II The first of two 700 teu cargo ship for the Bass Strait route between the Tasmanian port of Burnie and Read More
  • Race to Save Coral Reef After Grounding +

    Solomon Trader A major anti-pollution operation was launched in the Solomon Islands after the bulk carrier Solomon Trader, 73,592dwt, with a cargo Read More
  • Special Place for Tanker in Port History +

    Pro Alliance The largest fuel tanker in the 220 year history of the Australian port of Newcastle, NSW, arrived on Mar 18 Read More
  • Data Recorder Recovered From Ore Carrier Wreck +

    Seabed Constructor The Stellar Daisy, owned by Polaris Shipping, of South Korea, was carrying a cargo of iron ore from Brazil to Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Naval Focus

  • US Navy Orders Flight II Landing Platform Dock +

    LDP30 American News The contract for the construction of LPD30, the first Flight II Landing Platform Dock of the San Antonio Read More
  • US Navy Seeks Faster Ship Delivery +

    FFGX Rendering American News The future frigate program for the US Navy is getting fully underway and some idea of the urgency Read More
  • HMS “Dragon” in £75 Million Narcotics Seizure +

    HMS Dragon British News Whilst on patrol in the Gulf, the Type 45 destroyer HMS Dragon seized and destroyed ten tonnes of Read More
  • New Generation of Enterprise Confirmed +

    USS Enterprise American News On 31 January, the US Department of Defense announced the awarding of a block buy contract with Huntington Read More
  • Brazil to Take Over HMS Clyde +

    HMS Clyde British News It has been announced by the Brazilian Government in early December that the Falklands Patrol ship HMS Clyde Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ferry World

  • Further Delay for LNG Powered Glen Sannox +

    Glen Sannox The drama surrounding the much delayed new ferries for Caledonian MacBrayne continues to rumble on with the latest, not unsurprising, Read More
  • Favourite Claymore +

    Claymore A poster of Llandudno pier prompted a memory from ex Calmac chief engineer Charlie McCurdy as he took another trip Read More
  • Baltic Battery Power +

    Aurora Scandinavian and Baltic operators seem to be leading the way in reducing ferry reliance on fossil fuels. Read More
  • Electric Solutions +

    Polarkunsult Ferry A new ferry will replace the 1992-built MF Herjólfur to the Westmann Islands and will be in line with Iceland’s Read More
  • Variety of New Builds +

    Red Kestrel I am gratified to hear at Cammell Lairds and Red Funnel have a particularly good record in ordering from UK Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Sail Review/Coastal Comment

  • Thames Tributary Barges +

    Lady of the Lea Most of the rivers flowing into the Thames had their own barge type. Read More
  • Dry Rot and Dry Dock +

    HMS Victory For some time Victory, the 110gun ship of the line, has had trouble with dry rot and is in danger Read More
  • Everards Eulogy +

    Greenhithe Scottish maritime interests particularly may mourn the loss of Geo Gibson. Read More
  • Welsh Port Gentrification +

    Penarth In the Victorian era, there were many coastal places where craft worked off open beaches. Read More
  • Sussex Sterns +

    Edward and Mary and Valiant In the Victorian era, there were many coastal places where craft worked off open beaches. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

From the Lookout

  • Red Funnel’s New Ferry Arrives +

    Red Kestrel Red Kestrel, the newest addition to Red Funnel’s fleet, arrived at her new home in Southampton on 18 April. Read More
  • Keeping an Eye on the Weather +

    Royal Charter storm I was intrigued to read recently about the career of Vice-Admiral Robert FitzRoy (1805-65). Read More
  • Port of London Trade at 10-Year High +

    DP World London Gateway Trade through the Port of London reached 53.2 million tonnes last year, a level last seen over a decade ago. Read More
  • Northlink Celebrates Apprentices +

    Paul Wheelhouse NorthLink Serco Northlink Ferries has been commended by the Minister for Energy, Connectivity and the Islands, Paul Wheelhouse, for developing young Read More
  • An Auction with no Buyer +

    Falls of Clyde I was reading recently about the unsuccessful auction to find a buyer for the Falls of Clyde, the last remaining Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Cruise News/Superyacht News

  • Two Distinctive Ships Headed for Chinese Market +

    Spectrum of the Seas and Costa Venezia The Spectrum of the Seas (169,379 GT), Royal Caribbean International’s first ship in the Quantum Ultra Class, embarked on the Read More
  • Seadream Yacht Club to Build New Ship +

    SeaDream Innovation For over fifteen years, the SeaDream Yacht Club has operated two yachtlike ships, on 7 to 15-day voyages. Read More
  • Tradition Plays Its Part +

    Prana by Atzaro If ever proof was needed that traditionally built craft can still play a part in the luxury charter market in Read More
  • MV "Magellan Explorer" +

    MV Yet another new and modern expedition vessel custom built for Antarctic air-cruises will make her debut in 2019. Read More
  • The Saga Continues +

    Saga Discovery Saga Adventure SAGA Cruises has announced it is taking up an option for it’s second new ship to be built at the Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ships, Ports and Places

San Juan

A Truly Different Shipyard

The entrance to the port of Pasaia on the Spanish coast of Biscay is one of Europe’s most picturesque. At Read More

Victoria High and Dry

Five-hundred years ago, Ferdinand Magellan sailed out of Seville, Spain, on one of the most memorable discovery voyages ever made, Read More
  • 1
  • 2

Companies, Events and Other Features

SS Eastern (2)

MT Arthur Foss

“The last vessel to escape Wake Island before Japanese forces captured the island” Read More
SS Eastern (2)

Rescue of Crew Member From Tanker Avanti

Captain A J Murdoch served with Eastern & Australian Steamship Company until he retired in 1982. Hailing from Melbourne, during Read More
  • 1
  • 2