Tuesday, April 24, 2018
Prelude FLNG

The first part of this article in the February issue of Sea Breezes considered key trends in the evolution of oceangoing LNG ships from the first commercial cargo, in 1964, to the present day, noting in particular the growth in cargo capacity from 27,400m3 in the case of the Methane Princess to today’s standard of about 175,000m3. In recent years, the LNG industry has faced several significant technical challenges related to the floating production and re-gasifi cation of LNG, and the exploitation of gas reserves in Arctic regions.

Arctic LNG
During the 1970s much work was expended into assessing the feasibility of producing and exporting natural gas from the hydrocarbon-rich islands and offshore regions in the Canadian and Alaskan Arctic. One consideration for transporting the gas was to use submarines which, naturally, would be unaffected by surface ice and weather conditions. Moreover, prevailing water depths of over 350 metres would enable submarines to maintain cruising depth and speed over practically the entire length of the proposed routes. For this purpose, General Dynamics developed a series of designs of Arctic LNG submarines of 27~140,000m3. As well as nuclear propulsion, these designs featured a traditional steam-powered system using cargo boil-off gas (BOG) and, when submerged, re-circulated exhaust gas mixed with oxygen from a liquid oxygen tank. The idea of using submarines also came to the fore in studies of transporting natural gas in compressed form, but neither LNG nor CNG prototypes were ever built.

As an alternative to submarines, the Arctic Pilot Project conceived in 1976 by Petro-Canada and partners envisioned the use of two 140,000m3 ice-breaking LNG carriers each making about 15 round trips per year from a shipping terminal on the south coast of Melville Island located on the eastern side of Sabine Peninsula. The routing would take the ships in an easterly direction via Parry Channel, then across Baffin Bay and through Davies Strait to a receiving facility in St. John, New Brunswick. Dubbed the “Melville Island Monsters”, the ships were to be 372m long by 43m wide, and 11m draft, with three propeller shafts providing for 18.5 knots performance in open sea and a constant 3 knots through 2.1m thick first-year ice. Propulsion was to be electric, with six generators driven by six gas turbines, three capable of burning BOG and heavy fuel oil; the other trio just BOG.

Whilst the Arctic Pilot Project failed to make headway, the plans for the Melville Island monsters have, forty years later, many similarities to the ships being built for the Yamal LNG project in Siberia. In 2013, Daewoo Shipbuilding & Marine Engineering was chosen as the winning bidder to build fifteen 172,000m3 Arc-7 ice-class LNG ships for the project. With an enforced steel hull twenty-five percent thicker than equally-sized non ice-class ships, the Arc-7s are designed to pass continuously through ice up to 2.1 metres thick, and without the assistance of Russia’s nuclear icebreakers. The Russian Register Arc-7 standard is equivalent to an intermediate level between Polar Class 3 and Polar Class 4 of the international association of classification societies. The ships will be highly winterized enabling normal operation in -45 Celsius ambient temperature, with the equipment certified for work at -52 Celsius.

Starting at plateau output in 2020, and during each of the subsequent 25 years at least, the Yamal project will export 16.5 million tonnes of LNG. Shipments will be in a westbound direction from Sabetta port during winter and spring, and eastward in the other seasons when ice flows retreat sufficiently in the Northern Sea Route to enable Far Eastern markets to be served. Yamal’s main sponsor is Novatek with partners Total, and China National Petroleum Corporation; the Chinese being the key financiers. The first ship was launched in January 2016 and is due for delivery to Russian owner Sovcomflot in February 2017. It was to be named simply as SCF Yamal, but was eventually christened Christophe de Margerie in memory of the late President of Total who pushed the project forward despite western disapproval of the company’s backing of a major energy export project in Russia. On 20th October 2014, less than ten months after the final investment decision on the project, de Margerie was killed when his private jet collided with a snow plough when taking off from Moscow airport.

The Arc-7s are double-acting - designed to steam ahead in open water and thin ice, but turn around and proceed astern in heavy ice conditions. A key feature of the ships’ manoeuvrability in Yamal’s ice conditions are three 15 MW azimuth propulsion units – or azipods as manufacturers ABB has dubbed them – each consisting of a steerable pod containing an electric motor drive. The trio of pods will be powered by six Wartsila duel-fuel engines capable of handling the wide load variations that can occur when a ship passes through thick ice.

FLNG
Another technologically challenge witnessed by the LNG industry lately has been the development of floating production & liquefaction units – known as FLNGs – as sponsors seek to exploit small or remote offshore gas reserves for which traditional land-based facilities are unsuited. Floating liquefaction is not a new concept. In fact, it predates the first ships. Prior to the converted Methane Pioneer (a 1945-built Liberty ship) that delivered 7 cargoes from the US Gulf to Canvey Island, and before the first commercial cargo from Algeria to the UK, Chicago Stock Yards’ original concept in the 1950s was FLNG. The barge, tethered to shore, was a relatively simple design as compared to the sophisticated vessels presently being planned where the civil and chemical engineering of the topsides account for a much greater share of the challenges, and costs, than the hull.

It’s doubtful those pioneering fellows at Chicago Stock Yards could have envisioned the scope of Shell’s Prelude FLNG – the first to be ordered in the modern era – which, at 488m (1,600 feet) long, 74m (240 feet) wide and 44m (143 feet) deep from the keel to the main deck will, along with its contents, weigh around 600,000 tonnes. By comparison, the oil tanker Seawise Giant (1979~2009), generally considered the largest ship ever built, had a loaded displacement of 657,019 tonnes. Shell refers to Prelude FLNG, which will operate in waters of 200~250 metres’ depth, as a floating facility rather than a ship, and, as such, it will be the world’s largest ever built when eventually completed, in early 2018 perhaps, which would be almost three years behind the original schedule.

The behemoth, designed for 50 years’ service at various locations, will be towed to the Prelude gas field, some 475 kilometres north-east of Broome, Western Australia, and moored there for 20~25 years before needing to dock for inspection and overhaul. Each of three Rolls-Royce azimuth 5.2MW thrusters for local manoeuvring are situated at the base of a trunk that links to a higher maintenance workshop area with cranage. The Prelude FLNG facility is being built by Samsung Heavy Industries to TGZ membrane design and will produce annually 5.3 million tonnes of petroleum liquids – including 3.6 million tonnes of LNG.

The delays with Prelude have meant that it will not be the first offshore FLNG unit to be built; that feat was achieved by Petronas’ PFLNG Satu, ordered after the Shell contract, and delivered by Daewoo in May 2016. Of GT membrane design, the PFLNG Satu has been deployed at the Kanowit gas field off Sarawak where it will produce 1.2 million tonnes LNG per annum.

Unfortunately, the advent of FLNG has coincided with deep and protracted declines in oil and gas prices, making new project development less economic. Shell has cancelled options it had at Samsung to order three more of the giant units that would have been used to exploit other offshore gas fields. Petronas has postponed delivery of its second unit - the PFLG Dua - which had its keel-laying ceremony at Daewoo in April 2016 and is now expected not to be commissioned until 2020 – two years later than originally planned. More positively, Italians ENI and partners BP seem about ready to order an FLNG unit at Daewoo to develop a project at Coral South off Mozambique with 3.3 million tonnes per year of LNG.

Owners of older conventional LNG ships; of which a dozen or more have changed hands over the past couple of years, have been studying the prospects of converting them to FLNG units. Golar LNG – which has already converted the 1970s built Golar Spirit and Golar Freeze to floating storage & regasification units, or FSRUs described in the next section, is involved in projects that would entail converting ships of similar vintage to FLNG units.

Read the rest of this article with additional pictures in Sea Breezes Magazine - March 2017 Issue
Click here to subscribe

Subscribe Graphic

Latest Issue - Look Inside!

Game Changer

Most Popular

  • 1
  • 2

Top 10 Books and DVDs 2017

Maritime Log

  • More Warehousing to Meet Cargo Demand +

    Newport More warehousing to meet the growing demand for agriculture-related cargo is being built at Newport by the port’s owners Associated Read More
  • Cyber Security Put to the Test at Sea +

    Zim Genova The testing of a cyber security system for the classification society Lloyd’s Register has been successfully completed by the Israel-based Read More
  • Container Cranes to Boost Port Business +

    HHL Lagos Two new ship-to-shore gantry cranes worth £10.5mn are due to come into operation this month at the Hull Container Terminal, Read More
  • Ports Look To Future +

    BPA Logo A new Port Futures project to examine emerging threats and opportunities for British ports has been unveiled by the British Read More
  • River Barges Go Electric +

    Electric River Barge The Dutch inland barge operator Port-Liner is working on Europe’s first electrically-powered inland container ship with the Dutch electrical firm Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

North America

  • Icebreaker Delivers Two Supply Ships to US Antarctic Base +

    Polar Star The US Coast Guard’s only operational heavy icebreaker, the Polar Star, arrived at McMurdo Station, Antarctica, after completing her mission Read More
  • US Navy Plots its Course +

    images/content/news/201804/Ronald Regaan Theodore Roosevelt and Nimitz In February, the US Department of the Navy submitted its long-range ship acquisition plan to Congress as part of the Read More
  • Five Hurt in Engine Room Blaze +

    MOL Prestige Five crew were injured when the container ship MOL Prestige, 71,902gt, suffered an engine room fire more than 200 miles Read More
  • Commanding Officers Face Collisions Courts-Martial +

    USS Fitzgerald The US Navy destroyer Fitzgerald, which lost seven of her crew and was seriously damaged in a collision off Yokosuka, Read More
  • Anti-Drugs Patrols Seize Cocaine Worth $721m +

    USCG Stratton The US Coast Guard unloaded more than 47,000lbs of cocaine worth more than $721mn from the cutter Stratton at San Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Asia-Pacific

  • Eight More for Evergreen +

    Evergreen| The Evergreen Marine Corp of Taiwan, has ordered eight 11,000 teu container ships from the South Korean shipbuilder Samsung Heavy Read More
  • Andaman Islands Used for Trial Transshipment +

    Trina Oldendorff The trial transshipment of coal between two bulk carriers was carried out in the Andaman Islands in the Bay of Read More
  • Three Days of "Violent Fighting" on 10-Day Cruise +

    Carnival Legend The cruise ship Carnival Legend, 85,942gt, of Carnival Cruise Line Australia, had to put into the port of Eden on Read More
  • World’s First Cyber Container Ship Completed +

    COSCO Area The first container ship to have an energy management system that has been cyber-certified by the classification society Lloyd’s Register Read More
  • Two New Ferries Ordered for Bass Strait Service +

    Spirit of Tasmania II The TT-Line has ordered two new ferries for its Bass Strait service between Melbourne and Devonport on Tasmania’s north coast. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Naval Focus

  • Historic Port Visit to Vietnam +

    USS Carl Vinson US News In a significant move in March, the nuclear powered aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson made an historic port Read More
  • Russian Minesweeper Fleet Expands +

    Alexander Obukhov Russian News By 2027 the Russian Federation Navy is expected to have acquired a total of ten Alexandrit class minesweepers Read More
  • New Patrol ship for Danes +

    HDMS Lauge Koch Danish News On 11 December, in a ceremony held at Naval Station Korsør, the Royal Danish Navy commissioned the third Read More
  • Royal Navy ‘Cannibalising’ Ships for Parts +

    HMS Artful UK News Once again, the Royal Navy was in the headlines for all the wrong reasons in the closing months Read More
  • New Oiler for Canada +

    Asterix Canadian News The Royal Canadian Navy’s long wait for a new replenishment oiler for the fleet is nearly at an Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ferry World

  • Superfast Stena +

    Superfast VII Superfast VIII The issue of ferry operation, subsequent to the UK leaving the EU, will rather, regretfully, but unavoidably, continue to feature Read More
  • Sanctions Eased for Mangyongbong 92 +

    Mangyongbong 92 Ever since the 1950s when I was aware of the Soviet merchant marine’s Baltic SS Co vessels which linked Leningrad Read More
  • Estonian Arrow +

    Arrow Viv Llewellyn’s image of the IOM Steam Packet’s chartered Arrow at Poole indicates how advantageous her long term charter to Read More
  • A Classic Calais Blockade +

    Spirit of Britain A sign of worse to come? The 25th of January this year, saw French fishermen blockading the Port of Calais Read More
  • Lake Cruising +

    Western Belle In the English Lake District, on several of the Lakes, there are lake operations all year round. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Sail Review/Coastal Comment

  • Focus on Freshspring +

    Freshspring Severn Sea The Scandinavian connection this month, continues with the welcome reappearance of the magnificently versatile Severn Sea 147gt of Bideford seen Read More
  • Fame for Sandgrevstur +

    Vestborg and Sandfrakt I followed up the casualty Fame which featured in my last Coastal Commentary. Read More
  • Hollow Shore Sails +

    Alberta The Hollow Shore yard had been bought by the Testers who totally rebuilt several smacks including Primrose, Lily May, Ethel Read More
  • Nellie +

    Nellie The 75ft stumpie barge Nellie can be sailed single-handed by her owner Prof Diana Montgomery, because she doesn’t have a Read More
  • Ocean Troll +

    Ocean Troll Meanwhile, as the oil price is showing signs of recovery and the future of other oil and gas fi elds Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

From the Lookout

  • 2018 Spring Quilliam Lecture +

    Qilliam Lecture Poster "Quilliam Today" is is this year's title for the Spring Quilliam Lecture on Thursday 5th April in Arbory Church. Read More
  • Sydney – A Truly Magnificent Harbour +

    Sydney Harbour Recently, a friend visiting Australia sent me a few photographs of Circular Quay in Sydney. Read More
  • UK Chamber of Shipping Annual Dinner 2018 +

    Northlink Table The annual UK Chamber of Shipping Dinner is very much an occasion when ‘the great and good’ of the shipping Read More
  • The "Wahine" Disister +

    TEV Wahine 10th April 2018 marks the 50th anniversary of the tragic loss of the TEV Wahine in Wellington Harbour with the Read More
  • Medway Queen +

    Medway Queen As a result of a contact made thorough the Steam Boat Association of Great Britain in 2017, artist Mick Dean Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Cruise News/Superyacht News

  • The Bridge +

    Queen Mary 2 QM2 vs the Super Yachts race results between the St Nazaire Bridge and the Verrazano Bridge in New York Read More
  • Just A Storyline? +

    Marco Polo Notwithstanding a number of attempts to emulate “The World” by other operators, any past thoughts of competing with the only Read More
  • Ocean Liners Speed and Style +

    Ocean Liners: Speed and Style For those readers of this magazine who have a specific interest in ocean liners, and who live in greater London, Read More
  • The Beauty In The Beast +

    Ngoni The world of superyachts lost a great designer when Ed Dubois died in 2016. Read More
  • Slice Of The Action +

    YachtQuarters For those who find reading about yachts is not enough, and seek a slice of the action, here is news Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ships, Ports and Places

HMS Beagle

HMS Beagle - Voyages and Legacy

For one of the most famous vessels in the history of the Royal Navy and, arguably, the most influential ship Read More
SS Manipur

A Troubled Voyage on the SS Manipur

The last of my three deep-sea trips on the Brocklebank ship SS Manipur was as Junior Third Engineer offi cer Read More
  • 1
  • 2

Companies, Events and Other Features

HMS Vindictive

The Zeebrugge Raid

Prime Minister David Lloyd George spent the night of 22 April 1918 wide awake. He was noticeably on edge all Read More
The Mary Rose Museum

The Mary Rose

The discovery and raising of the wreck of Henry VIII’s flag ship the Mary Rose is one of the greatest Read More
  • 1
  • 2