Tuesday, April 24, 2018
HMS Vindictive

Prime Minister David Lloyd George spent the night of 22 April 1918 wide awake. He was noticeably on edge all that long night as he waited with growing impatience for news from the continent - what Sir Winston Churchill would later call ‘the finest feat of arms in the Great War’. The raid of which he spoke was that planned against the port installations of Zeebrugge and Ostend.

The importance of these ports to Germany were paramount, and to the British their capture or destruction was of equal importance. First Sea Lord Admiral Sir John Jellicoe pessimistically declared in June 1917 that, if the ports of Ostend and Zeebrugge were not denied to enemy forces, the Allies could easily lose the war. A land assault was planned by General Sir Douglas Haig, but the Prime Minister was not prepared to accept the projected casualties; especially after the disastrous campaigns at Messines, the Third Ypres and the Battle of Passchendale.

What was needed was another option. Aerial attack by aircraft of the RAF was also considered inadequate, which left the Royal Navy and the Marines.

Zeebrugge, and to a lesser extent Ostend, had been utilised by the German navy as a base for coastal torpedo boats which harassed Allied shipping to the continent. These small fast craft were inexpensive to build and man, and caused considerable destruction of much larger and more expensive warships and supply ships.

Planning for the Zeebrugge raid had commenced in late 1916, as it was felt a full invasion of the Belgian coast would come with too high a price in men and equipment. In November 1916, then Prime Minister Herbert Asquith gathered the heads of the armed forces for a conference. Sometime during the meeting he turned to the Chief of the Imperial General Staff Field Marshall Sir Henry Wilson and said, “There is no operation to which the War Committee attaches greater importance than the deprivation to the enemy of Ostend and Zeebrugge.”

Within that day, detailed planning commenced and key appointments were made. Commodore Reginald Tyrwhitt proposed an amphibious assault on the mole that stretched out into the North Sea at Zeebrugge, and the sinking of blockships at the entrance to the Bruges Canal. All of 1,698 men, including officers and 660 Royal Marines, started two months of intensive special training for the operations to come. Crucially, every last man was a volunteer.

Naval Preparations
Over one-hundred small and medium-sized vessels were collected in the Thames estuary hidden away from spies and reconnaissance aircraft. Many were given extra armament. For the Royal Navy, this meant adding some unusual equipment to the veteran cruiser HMS Vindictive, including an 11-inch Howitzer flame throwers, stokes mortars and a dozen long-hinged brows on her port side to allow the Royal Marines off at speed.

Five elderly cruisers of 3,600 tons, HMS Brilliant, HMS Iphigenia, HMS Intrepid, HMS Sirius and HMS Thetis were selected to be used as the block ships. For this role, each had 1,500 tons of concrete poured into their hulls as well as electrically-fired scuttling charges. Two obsolete submarines, C1 and C3, were loaded with large explosive charges in their forward compartments, and the upper works of the Mersey ferries Iris II and Daffodil were provided with bulletproof plating backed up by mattresses.

The date chosen for the attack was 11 April and, under the command of Rear Admiral Roger Keyes, the force sailed. At 2300, the force split into two with those ships destined to attack Ostend under the command of Commodore H Lynes sailing on a different course. Rear Admiral Roger Keyes onboard the destroyer HMS Warwick continued on to Zeebrugge. At the stroke of midnight, the ships commenced a blistering bombardment of both ports while a large flotilla of motor torpedo boats laid a smokescreen. Sadly for the British, the wind that night was not ideal and the smokescreen was ineffective, forcing Keyes to reluctantly cancel the operation and return home.

On the second attempt on 13 August, the wind - this time a gale - once again tore into the British plans, forcing Keyes to cancel the attack.

The weather was not the only problem to befall the raid. British secret operational orders for the grounded fast torpedo boat CMB33 were obtained by Admiral von Schroder, the Commander of German coast defences. Fortunately, the Germans failed to make the most of the information and failed to fully protect Zeebrugge.

For Keyes, he hoped that, third time, would be lucky when the fleet sailed on the afternoon of 22 April, the eve of St George’s Day. This gave Keyes an idea to boost morale. From his ship, he signalled “St George for England”. Captain AFB Carpenter, in command of HMS Vindictive replied, “May we give the dragon’s tail a damned good twist.”

The German defences at Zeebrugge were impressive. Lined up against any attacking force were 225 guns of which 136 were 6-15 inch. As the British monitors HMS Erebus and HMS Terror started their bombardment at 23.50, the Germans fired back at the glimpsed targets seen through the heavy smokescreen. At 23.50, however, the defenders were shocked to see the 5,750 tons of the cruiser HMS Vindictive tearing towards the mole at just 1,500 metres distance. They did not panic, but instead wrought deadly withering fire onto the British cruiser, decimating the naval and marines’ storming parties which had been standing ready on her upper deck and superstructure. Among the dead were their commanders Captain H C Halahan and Lieutenant Colonel B N Elliot.

The first block ship, HMS Thetis, sailed out of the smokescreen into withering fire before fouling on a net obstruction, and then grounding. Her crew set the scuttling charges and abandoned the ship away from her planned position. HMS Thetis was a failure, but the next ship, HMS Intrepid was not. Lieutenant S Bonham-Carter took his ship straight into the canal’s mouth and scuttled her. Her sister ship HMS Iphigenia followed her in. The pair effectively blocked the canal by turning their wheels hard over and sticking fast in the tight and narrow entrance.

Read the rest of this article with additional pictures in Sea Breezes Magazine - April 2018 Issue
Click here to subscribe

Subscribe Graphic

Latest Issue - Look Inside!

Game Changer

Most Popular

  • 1
  • 2

Top 10 Books and DVDs 2017

Maritime Log

  • More Warehousing to Meet Cargo Demand +

    Newport More warehousing to meet the growing demand for agriculture-related cargo is being built at Newport by the port’s owners Associated Read More
  • Cyber Security Put to the Test at Sea +

    Zim Genova The testing of a cyber security system for the classification society Lloyd’s Register has been successfully completed by the Israel-based Read More
  • Container Cranes to Boost Port Business +

    HHL Lagos Two new ship-to-shore gantry cranes worth £10.5mn are due to come into operation this month at the Hull Container Terminal, Read More
  • Ports Look To Future +

    BPA Logo A new Port Futures project to examine emerging threats and opportunities for British ports has been unveiled by the British Read More
  • River Barges Go Electric +

    Electric River Barge The Dutch inland barge operator Port-Liner is working on Europe’s first electrically-powered inland container ship with the Dutch electrical firm Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

North America

  • Icebreaker Delivers Two Supply Ships to US Antarctic Base +

    Polar Star The US Coast Guard’s only operational heavy icebreaker, the Polar Star, arrived at McMurdo Station, Antarctica, after completing her mission Read More
  • US Navy Plots its Course +

    images/content/news/201804/Ronald Regaan Theodore Roosevelt and Nimitz In February, the US Department of the Navy submitted its long-range ship acquisition plan to Congress as part of the Read More
  • Five Hurt in Engine Room Blaze +

    MOL Prestige Five crew were injured when the container ship MOL Prestige, 71,902gt, suffered an engine room fire more than 200 miles Read More
  • Commanding Officers Face Collisions Courts-Martial +

    USS Fitzgerald The US Navy destroyer Fitzgerald, which lost seven of her crew and was seriously damaged in a collision off Yokosuka, Read More
  • Anti-Drugs Patrols Seize Cocaine Worth $721m +

    USCG Stratton The US Coast Guard unloaded more than 47,000lbs of cocaine worth more than $721mn from the cutter Stratton at San Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3


  • Eight More for Evergreen +

    Evergreen| The Evergreen Marine Corp of Taiwan, has ordered eight 11,000 teu container ships from the South Korean shipbuilder Samsung Heavy Read More
  • Andaman Islands Used for Trial Transshipment +

    Trina Oldendorff The trial transshipment of coal between two bulk carriers was carried out in the Andaman Islands in the Bay of Read More
  • Three Days of "Violent Fighting" on 10-Day Cruise +

    Carnival Legend The cruise ship Carnival Legend, 85,942gt, of Carnival Cruise Line Australia, had to put into the port of Eden on Read More
  • World’s First Cyber Container Ship Completed +

    COSCO Area The first container ship to have an energy management system that has been cyber-certified by the classification society Lloyd’s Register Read More
  • Two New Ferries Ordered for Bass Strait Service +

    Spirit of Tasmania II The TT-Line has ordered two new ferries for its Bass Strait service between Melbourne and Devonport on Tasmania’s north coast. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Naval Focus

  • Historic Port Visit to Vietnam +

    USS Carl Vinson US News In a significant move in March, the nuclear powered aircraft carrier USS Carl Vinson made an historic port Read More
  • Russian Minesweeper Fleet Expands +

    Alexander Obukhov Russian News By 2027 the Russian Federation Navy is expected to have acquired a total of ten Alexandrit class minesweepers Read More
  • New Patrol ship for Danes +

    HDMS Lauge Koch Danish News On 11 December, in a ceremony held at Naval Station Korsør, the Royal Danish Navy commissioned the third Read More
  • Royal Navy ‘Cannibalising’ Ships for Parts +

    HMS Artful UK News Once again, the Royal Navy was in the headlines for all the wrong reasons in the closing months Read More
  • New Oiler for Canada +

    Asterix Canadian News The Royal Canadian Navy’s long wait for a new replenishment oiler for the fleet is nearly at an Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ferry World

  • Superfast Stena +

    Superfast VII Superfast VIII The issue of ferry operation, subsequent to the UK leaving the EU, will rather, regretfully, but unavoidably, continue to feature Read More
  • Sanctions Eased for Mangyongbong 92 +

    Mangyongbong 92 Ever since the 1950s when I was aware of the Soviet merchant marine’s Baltic SS Co vessels which linked Leningrad Read More
  • Estonian Arrow +

    Arrow Viv Llewellyn’s image of the IOM Steam Packet’s chartered Arrow at Poole indicates how advantageous her long term charter to Read More
  • A Classic Calais Blockade +

    Spirit of Britain A sign of worse to come? The 25th of January this year, saw French fishermen blockading the Port of Calais Read More
  • Lake Cruising +

    Western Belle In the English Lake District, on several of the Lakes, there are lake operations all year round. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Sail Review/Coastal Comment

  • Focus on Freshspring +

    Freshspring Severn Sea The Scandinavian connection this month, continues with the welcome reappearance of the magnificently versatile Severn Sea 147gt of Bideford seen Read More
  • Fame for Sandgrevstur +

    Vestborg and Sandfrakt I followed up the casualty Fame which featured in my last Coastal Commentary. Read More
  • Hollow Shore Sails +

    Alberta The Hollow Shore yard had been bought by the Testers who totally rebuilt several smacks including Primrose, Lily May, Ethel Read More
  • Nellie +

    Nellie The 75ft stumpie barge Nellie can be sailed single-handed by her owner Prof Diana Montgomery, because she doesn’t have a Read More
  • Ocean Troll +

    Ocean Troll Meanwhile, as the oil price is showing signs of recovery and the future of other oil and gas fi elds Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

From the Lookout

  • 2018 Spring Quilliam Lecture +

    Qilliam Lecture Poster "Quilliam Today" is is this year's title for the Spring Quilliam Lecture on Thursday 5th April in Arbory Church. Read More
  • Sydney – A Truly Magnificent Harbour +

    Sydney Harbour Recently, a friend visiting Australia sent me a few photographs of Circular Quay in Sydney. Read More
  • UK Chamber of Shipping Annual Dinner 2018 +

    Northlink Table The annual UK Chamber of Shipping Dinner is very much an occasion when ‘the great and good’ of the shipping Read More
  • The "Wahine" Disister +

    TEV Wahine 10th April 2018 marks the 50th anniversary of the tragic loss of the TEV Wahine in Wellington Harbour with the Read More
  • Medway Queen +

    Medway Queen As a result of a contact made thorough the Steam Boat Association of Great Britain in 2017, artist Mick Dean Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Cruise News/Superyacht News

  • The Bridge +

    Queen Mary 2 QM2 vs the Super Yachts race results between the St Nazaire Bridge and the Verrazano Bridge in New York Read More
  • Just A Storyline? +

    Marco Polo Notwithstanding a number of attempts to emulate “The World” by other operators, any past thoughts of competing with the only Read More
  • Ocean Liners Speed and Style +

    Ocean Liners: Speed and Style For those readers of this magazine who have a specific interest in ocean liners, and who live in greater London, Read More
  • The Beauty In The Beast +

    Ngoni The world of superyachts lost a great designer when Ed Dubois died in 2016. Read More
  • Slice Of The Action +

    YachtQuarters For those who find reading about yachts is not enough, and seek a slice of the action, here is news Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ships, Ports and Places

HMS Beagle

HMS Beagle - Voyages and Legacy

For one of the most famous vessels in the history of the Royal Navy and, arguably, the most influential ship Read More
SS Manipur

A Troubled Voyage on the SS Manipur

The last of my three deep-sea trips on the Brocklebank ship SS Manipur was as Junior Third Engineer offi cer Read More
  • 1
  • 2

Companies, Events and Other Features

HMS Vindictive

The Zeebrugge Raid

Prime Minister David Lloyd George spent the night of 22 April 1918 wide awake. He was noticeably on edge all Read More
The Mary Rose Museum

The Mary Rose

The discovery and raising of the wreck of Henry VIII’s flag ship the Mary Rose is one of the greatest Read More
  • 1
  • 2