Monday, December 11, 2017
Sea Breezes Editor, Hamish Ross

Time for a full investigation of the coastal sector

In Sea Breezes we have raised the matter of the loss of the cement carrier MV Cemfjord (Cyprus Flag) on several occasions. At the beginning of January 2015, in severe weather, the Cemfjord was in the Pentland Firth when she was overwhelmed suddenly and catastrophically with the loss of all hands onboard – eight men in all.

The subsequent Marine Accident Investigation Board (MAIB) report into the loss of the Cemfjord revealed quite clearly that there were serious shortcomings in several areas of the operation of this vessel. Readers can access this report at www.gov.uk/maib-reports/capsizeand- sinking-of-cement-carrier-cemfjord-with-loss-of-8-lives.

I said in my Message From The Bridge, Sea Breezes, July 2016, that we owed it to the men lost on the Cemfjord, and indeed to all seafarers in the coastal trade that action should be taken to address the shortcomings exposed in the MAIB Report to prevent such an incident in the future. Cemfjord was at sea with significant safety shortcomings and indeed it was only the granting of Flag State exemptions from some safety regulations that had allowed the Cemfjord to proceed to sea. I also said in reference to various shipping disasters “Whether investigations ultimately reveal flawed systems and procedures, human error, poor maintenance, failure by regulators and inspectors, faults in vessel design/construction or indeed a combination of more than one of these factors, we owe it to all who sail on ships – big or small – to take every possible step to make safety at sea our number one priority.

Well yes indeed – as we are all fond of saying “lessons will be learned“, but will they?

Looking up on my computer the list of “Foreign Flag Ships under detention in the UK during February 2017“ (published in March 2017) I noted that the cement carrier Cemgulf (Cyprus Flag) was detained at Ellesmere Port from 15th February-24th February 2017 with six deficiencies – with four grounds for detention. These deficiencies included – missing nautical publications; onboard training and instruction – lack of training; inoperative lifeboats; ISM – not as required; voyage and passage plan – lack of information.

In my July 2016 piece I also reported that in a Press Release following the loss of the Cemfjord and the publication of the MAIB Report Steve Todd, National Secretary of the RMT said “If the coastal sector was compliant with international safety standards, eight seafarers would be alive today and their families would not be grieving their loss. We welcome the MAIB Report which tells us that this catastrophic loss could have been avoided. Coastal freight traffic should be a success story for maritime skills and in shifting more cargo off roads. Instead it is an industry that plays fast and loose with international maritime regulations and ultimately with seafarers lives. Whilst we note that mandatory reporting in the Pentland Firth has recommenced, the UK Government needs to stop describing high maritime safety standards as “gold plating” and get a grip on this vital, but badly regulated sector, before more seafarers lose their lives. A Public Enquiry into coastal shipping would be the best way to achieve that.“

“In recent months I have read of several examples of ships operating around the UK coast flouting safety and labour standards. I therefore would support the need and call for a full investigation of the coastal sector of our shipping industry.” In the meantime our ‘coastal state‘ inspection regime should be strictly implemented and applied.

HAMISH ROSS, EDITOR

Subscribe Graphic

Latest Issue - Look Inside!

GMS Expedition

Most Popular

  • 1
  • 2

Top 10 Books and DVDs 2017

Maritime Log

  • Falklands War Successor is Broken Up +

    Atlantic Conveyor A ship that was built on the Tyne for the Cunard Steam-Ship Co, of Liverpool, to replace one that was Read More
  • Historic Lifeboat Returns Home +

    Bedford A historic lifeboat has returned home to Tyneside after a number of local businesses joined local government to save her. Read More
  • Anchor Catches Torpedo +

    Skaw Provider When the crew of the Maltese-flag oil/chemical tanker Skaw Provider, 4,300dwt, raised the anchor from 15m off Portland, Dorset, they Read More
  • Side-By-Side Supply Ships Sink +

    The Maersk Searcher and Maersk Shipper. (DMAIB) A unique conjunction of events and circumstances led to the sinking of two Maersk offshore supply vessels in December, 2016, Read More
  • Historic Voyage Between China and Russia +

    Lian Hua Song The cargo ship Lian Hua Song (pictured) 20,692gt, of the COSCO Shipping Line, China, arrived at St Petersburg, Russia, in Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

North America

  • Bid To Curb Act And Boost Aid To Island +

    Horizon Spirit As Puerto Rico recovers from the series of devastating hurricanes this season, it has been claimed that the Jones Act Read More
  • ‘Best Trading Months’ in History of Long Beach +

    Port Of Long Beach Records were broken in September when the Port of Long Beach, California, moved more containers than in any other September Read More
  • Hudson's Biggest +

    Steam generator The two-day, 170-mile delivery from the Port of Coeymans near Albany, New York of a new 130-foot high steam generator Read More
  • "Friendship of Salem" to Return This Winter +

    Friendship of Salem The Salem Maritime National Historic Site announced agreement on contract changes for the ongoing overhaul of the three-masted, 171-foot Friendship Read More
  • You're Fired! +

    USS John S McCain After a grounding, three collisions and multiple deaths, Vice Adm Joseph Aucoin was relieved of command of the US Navy’s Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Asia-Pacific

  • Stranded Cargo Ship to be Refloated and Broken Up +

    Kea Trader The container ship Kea Trader, 24,720gt, which went aground on a reef off New Caledonia on July 12, will have Read More
  • Italian Builders to Construct in Australia +

    Fincantieri The Italian shipbuilder and ship designer Fincantieri is to construct sections for cruise ships and frigates in Australia from next Read More
  • Fifteen LNG Carriers For Siberia Project +

    LNG Ice Breaker (DSME) A South Korean company has received a contract to build 15 ice-breaking LNG carriers for Russia, the president of South Read More
  • Asia/Australasia Container Traffic Slumps +

    Drewry Report Container traffic from Asia to Australasia suffered its first quarterly slump in at least five years, falling by 11 per Read More
  • First Order from Taiwan +

    Austal The fast ferry builder Austal Ships, of Henderson, Western Australia, has won its first commercial vessel contract in Taiwan. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Naval Focus

  • New Oiler for Canada +

    Asterix Canadian News The Royal Canadian Navy’s long wait for a new replenishment oiler for the fleet is nearly at an Read More
  • HMS Queen Elizabeth Arrives at Home Port +

    HMS Queen Elizabeth British News An event following the 2010 Defence Review many thought would never happen occurred on Wednesday 16 August when Read More
  • Work Starts on Three Warships +

    Type 25 British News After an almost unseemly wait, the Royal Navy can breathe again having held its breath waiting for the Read More
  • Los Angeles Class Decommissioning +

    USS Dallas American News The end of May saw a lot of submarine news within the US Navy with the decommissioning of Read More
  • HMS Westminster Returns to Service +

    HMS Westminster British News After two years out of service undergoing a major reconstruction and refit, the Type 23 frigate HMS Westminster Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ferry World

  • Nostalgic Scout Trip Remembered +

    South Shields Scouts A morale boosting and nostalgic story from not long after WW2 came to my notice. Read More
  • Morale Boost for CalMac +

    Glen Sannox The major new units of CalMac’s West of Scotland fleet taking shape at Port Glasgow are to bear the much Read More
  • Summer Scenes - Naples +

    GNV Cristal So when arriving at Naples, we now meet the ex Olau Hollandia ex Pride of Le Havre ex SNAV Sardegna, Read More
  • Summer Scenes - Barcelona +

    Abel Matutes As we head through Autumn – or ‘the Fall’ as our North American readers would put it – and some of the Read More
  • Excursion Woes +

    Waverley The excursion business, especially with the preserved classic vessels, has continued to have major disappointments. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Sail Review/Coastal Comment

  • From Rix To Stevie Clarkes +

    “Ronrix” leaving for Hull The name Rix is long associated with Humber ports with origins traced to Hull businessman Captain Robert Rix in the Read More
  • Energy Needs +

    Northern Ocean Charlie McCurdy’s fine image of the Faeroese products tanker Northern Ocean 8,594,’98 passing Greenock, on her way from the fuel Read More
  • Staple Trades - Clay +

    Moelfre Rose Before leaving the economically confused days of 2017, I thought I would remind ourselves of some of the staple trades Read More
  • Colne Racing +

    Edme The 46th Colne Smack and Barge Match was sailed from Brightlingsea on September 2 in a very light southerly breeze Read More
  • West Coast Restorations +

    CA Thayer From the day they are launched, every ship has a life expectancy. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

From the Lookout

  • TMG Delivers Influential Panama Canal Study +

    MSC Antalya A global maritime consultancy has carried out a pivotal assessment review of tugboat operations in the new third set of Read More
  • The Majestic River Rhine +

    MS Charles Dickens In September of this year, my wife and I enjoyed a wonderful Riviera Travel river cruise on the majestic River Read More
  • Video Campaign for New Seafarers +

    To Sea or Not to Sea In an aim to plug the shortfall in numbers of British seafarers, the UK Chamber of Shipping and the Merchant Read More
  • Solent Marine Safety Academy +

    Firefighters Any initiative that helps improve safety at sea and the betterment of the skills set of seafarers in reacting to Read More
  • Forth Bridges - The New Queensferry Crossing +

    Forth Bridges At the end of August 2017, the new Queensferry Crossing opened to traffic. Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Cruise News/Superyacht News

  • Curaçao’s Colours and Bridges +

    Queen Emma Bridge Many ports of the world that attract cruise traffic are well known for certain iconic aspects that they possess. Read More
  • Shaw Savill and Albion’s New Build ‘Game Changer’ +

    Southern Cross Shaw Savill and Albion’s new build in 1955, the Southern Cross, was a remarkable vessel for a number of reasons. Read More
  • Britain's Boat Builders are Buoyant +

    British Sunseeker 95 Yacht Brand new industry reports, prepared by British Marine, show that Britain’s boat builders are buoyant and riding the crest of Read More
  • Project Echo +

    Project Echo Having recently delivered the 46m composite catamaran yacht support vessel, Charley, to the owners of the superyacht White Rabbit Golf, Read More
  • Two Unique Ships Meet In Douglas Bay +

    Sega Sapphire and Talitha When Hapag-Lloyd’s new build, the Europa (3), was delivered to the company in 1981, the vessel very quickly was awarded Read More
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Ships, Ports and Places

John Readhead & Sons

The Role of the Yard Pilot

Anyone who has attended a ship launch will forever remember the thrill of the occasion as the vessel begins its Read More
Duke of Lancaster

TSS Duke of Lancaster

A Typical Summer Sailing From Heysham Harbour – 50 Years Ago Read More
  • 1
  • 2

Companies, Events and Other Features

Low Walker

The Mysterious Ways

When I started work at Low Walker, a Newcastle on Tyne engineering company which was located right next to the Read More
Imo

The Halifax Explosion

On 29th December, 1950, Cairnesk put into Halifax, Nova Scotia, on the first call of the ‘winter schedule’. Read More
  • 1
  • 2